widescreen/fullscreen part deux.

[peacefully.livejournal.com]

I'm redoing my Ever After caps and I posted a question yesterday. Which do you prefer screencaps of, Widescreen or Fullscreen? Most people said widescreen (usually with the added comment that fullscreen cuts stuff off) so I did a lot them that way. Then, when I compared the widescreen caps with one of my old full screen ones, I noticed just how much is missing from the widescreen ones. I guess how much is cut from what depends on the movie.
Examples:
widescreen.
fullscreen.

Now, there's no way I'm going to go back and redo the 229 caps I've already done (out of 33 minutes of movie), but the widescreen really seems to be missing a lot more than the full screen is, and I, personally, would prefer the full screen ones for making icons. I don't want the set to be mismatched, but I don't want to post a huge set of half-screen shots.
I think from now on, when capping a DVD that gives me the choice, I'll take one from each and see which cuts less off and do those, but I don't know what to do about my Ever After set.
So should I continue doing them wide screen, or do the rest of the set in fullscreen?

(if this isn't allowed, let me know and I'll delete the post.)

Comments

[peacefully.livejournal.com]

I should probably have mentioned this, but forgot. See, that's the reason I'm redoing them. Originally I had my settings wrong and that's why the aspect ratio on that picture is off.
The example of fullscreen that I showed is one of my old ones and part of the reason I'm redoing them. It's squished because of my old settings, not because it's fullscreen. Now, they are fine. The only difference now is that half of the picture is missing from the widescreen picture.
I guess I'll just finish the set in widescreen and hope people can get some use from them with half the picture missing.